The Butt Plugs Collection meets our unique industry-leading quality and performance standards. All items are backed by the Sexual Toys® 100% Satisfaction Guarantee!
865 products
-
Rear Assets Rose Anal Plug - Medium - PinkVendor:Rear Assets Rose Anal Plug - Medium - PinkNS Novelties
- Regular price
-
$10.88 - Regular price
-
$20.00 - Sale price
-
$10.88
Quick view
-
Rear Assets Rose Anal Plug - Medium - PurpleVendor:Rear Assets Rose Anal Plug - Medium - PurpleNS Novelties
- Regular price
-
$10.88 - Regular price
-
$20.00 - Sale price
-
$10.88
Quick view
-
Rear Assets Rose Anal Plug - Medium - RedVendor:Rear Assets Rose Anal Plug - Medium - RedNS Novelties
- Regular price
-
$10.88 - Regular price
-
$20.00 - Sale price
-
$10.88
Quick view
-
Anal Adventures Basic Anal Plug - Small BlackVendor:Anal Adventures Basic Anal Plug - Small BlackBlush
- Regular price
-
$7.88 - Regular price
-
$15.00 - Sale price
-
$7.88
Quick view
-
Ouch! Regular Lucky Diamond Butt Plug - BlackVendor:Ouch! Regular Lucky Diamond Butt Plug - BlackShots
- Regular price
-
$12.88 - Regular price
-
$22.00 - Sale price
-
$12.88
Quick view
-
Ouch! Large Lucky Diamond Butt Plug - BlackVendor:Ouch! Large Lucky Diamond Butt Plug - BlackShots
- Regular price
-
$13.88 - Regular price
-
$24.00 - Sale price
-
$13.88
Quick view
-
Forto F-30: Pointer Med
Quick view
-
Forto F-98: Cone Small
Quick view
-
Forto F-98: Cone Large
Quick view
-
Forto F-21: Tear Drop SmallVendor:Forto F-21: Tear Drop SmallForto
- Regular price
-
From
$13.88 - Regular price
-
$24.00 - Sale price
-
From
$13.88
Quick view
-
Forto F-11: Lungo Sm
Quick view
-
Forto F-11: Lungo Med
Quick view
-
The 9'S Glass Thins Cylindrical Glass PlugVendor:The 9'S Glass Thins Cylindrical Glass PlugIcon
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
-
The 9'S Glass Thins Elliptical Glass PlugVendor:The 9'S Glass Thins Elliptical Glass PlugIcon
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
-
The 9'S Cottontails Silicone Bunny Tail Butt Plug Ribbed PinkVendor:The 9'S Cottontails Silicone Bunny Tail Butt Plug Ribbed PinkIcon
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
-
The 9'S Cottontails Silicone Bunny Tail Butt Plug Ribbed PurpleVendor:The 9'S Cottontails Silicone Bunny Tail Butt Plug Ribbed PurpleIcon
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
-
The 9'S Cottontails Silicone Bunny Tail Butt Plug Beaded PinkVendor:The 9'S Cottontails Silicone Bunny Tail Butt Plug Beaded PinkIcon
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
-
The 9'S Cottontails Silicone Bunny Tail Butt Plug Beaded PurpleVendor:The 9'S Cottontails Silicone Bunny Tail Butt Plug Beaded PurpleIcon
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
-
Rooster Alpha Advanced Anal Plug BlackVendor:Rooster Alpha Advanced Anal Plug BlackSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$12.88 - Regular price
-
$23.00 - Sale price
-
$12.88
Quick view
-
Rooster Alpha Advanced Anal Plug OrangeVendor:Rooster Alpha Advanced Anal Plug OrangeSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$12.88 - Regular price
-
$23.00 - Sale price
-
$12.88
Quick view
-
Rooster Alpha Anal Plug BlackVendor:Rooster Alpha Anal Plug BlackSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$10.88 - Regular price
-
$20.00 - Sale price
-
$10.88
Quick view
-
Luv Inc Jp31 Jeweled Small Plug With 3 Stones RedVendor:Luv Inc Jp31 Jeweled Small Plug With 3 Stones RedSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$9.88 - Regular price
-
$18.00 - Sale price
-
$9.88
Quick view
-
Luv Inc Jp32 Jeweled Medium Plug With 3 Stones Light PinkVendor:Luv Inc Jp32 Jeweled Medium Plug With 3 Stones Light PinkPink
- Regular price
-
$11.88 - Regular price
-
$21.00 - Sale price
-
$11.88
Quick view
-
Luv Inc Jp33 Jeweled Large Plug With 3 Stones CoralVendor:Luv Inc Jp33 Jeweled Large Plug With 3 Stones CoralSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$13.88 - Regular price
-
$24.00 - Sale price
-
$13.88
Quick view
-
Ouch! Black & White Silicone Butt Plug With Removable Jewel BlackVendor:Ouch! Black & White Silicone Butt Plug With Removable Jewel BlackSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$11.88 - Regular price
-
$21.00 - Sale price
-
$11.88
Quick view
-
Gyro-M 10X Curved Rimming Plug With Remote ControlVendor:Gyro-M 10X Curved Rimming Plug With Remote ControlSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$65.89 - Regular price
-
$98.00 - Sale price
-
$65.89
Quick view
-
Remote Control Wagging And Vibrating Puppy Tail Anal PlugVendor:Remote Control Wagging And Vibrating Puppy Tail Anal PlugTailz
- Regular price
-
$85.89 - Regular price
-
$126.00 - Sale price
-
$85.89
Quick view
-
Gape-Grommets 3 Piece Hollow Silicone Anal Dilator SetVendor:Gape-Grommets 3 Piece Hollow Silicone Anal Dilator SetMaster Series
- Regular price
-
$49.89 - Regular price
-
$76.00 - Sale price
-
$49.89
Quick view
-
Premium Silicone Weighted Anal Plug - LargeVendor:Premium Silicone Weighted Anal Plug - LargeHeavy Hitters
- Regular price
-
$27.88 - Regular price
-
$42.00 - Sale price
-
$27.88
Quick view
-
Premium Silicone Weighted Anal Plug - MediumVendor:Premium Silicone Weighted Anal Plug - MediumHeavy Hitters
- Regular price
-
$23.88 - Regular price
-
$37.00 - Sale price
-
$23.88
Quick view
-
Waggerz Remote Control Wagging Fox Tail Anal PlugVendor:Waggerz Remote Control Wagging Fox Tail Anal PlugTailz
- Regular price
-
$81.89 - Regular price
-
$121.00 - Sale price
-
$81.89
Quick view
-
Dark Hive Metal, Silicone Ribbed Anal PlugVendor:Dark Hive Metal, Silicone Ribbed Anal PlugMaster Series
- Regular price
-
$27.88 - Regular price
-
$43.00 - Sale price
-
$27.88
Quick view
-
Under Control Vibrating Anal Plug With Remote ControlVendor:Under Control Vibrating Anal Plug With Remote ControlUnder Control
- Regular price
-
$53.89 - Regular price
-
$81.00 - Sale price
-
$53.89
Quick view
-
Pedigree Puppy Play Tail Butt Plug BlackVendor:Pedigree Puppy Play Tail Butt Plug BlackMaster Series
- Regular price
-
$25.88 - Regular price
-
$40.00 - Sale price
-
$25.88
Quick view
-
Ember Weighted Tapered Anal Plug Glass ClearVendor:Ember Weighted Tapered Anal Plug Glass ClearPrisms Erotic Glass
- Regular price
-
$25.88 - Regular price
-
$40.00 - Sale price
-
$25.88
Quick view
-
Cat Tail Silicone Anal PlugVendor:Cat Tail Silicone Anal PlugTailz
- Regular price
-
$35.88 - Regular price
-
$53.00 - Sale price
-
$35.88
Quick view
-
The Silver Starter Rose Floral Steel Butt Plug PurpleVendor:The Silver Starter Rose Floral Steel Butt Plug PurpleThe Nines
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
-
Oxballs Ergo Buttplug Small - Platinum SwirlVendor:Oxballs Ergo Buttplug Small - Platinum SwirlOxballs
- Regular price
-
$31.88 - Regular price
-
$48.00 - Sale price
-
$31.88
Quick view
-
Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Anal Ball W/Vibrating C Ring - BlackVendor:Anal Adventures Platinum Silicone Anal Ball W/Vibrating C Ring - BlackBlush
- Regular price
-
$20.88 - Regular price
-
$34.00 - Sale price
-
$20.88
Quick view
-
Anal Adventures Orb Plug - BlackVendor:Anal Adventures Orb Plug - BlackBlush
- Regular price
-
$10.88 - Regular price
-
$20.00 - Sale price
-
$10.88
Quick view
The Butt Plugs Collection features the industry's leading sexual toys and novelty product manufacturers. We appreciate your desire for a large selection and high quality. We ship these in-stock items multiple times per day for lightening fast order processing. Thank you for shopping with us, click the button below to return to the home page.