The Butt Plugs Collection meets our unique industry-leading quality and performance standards. All items are backed by the Sexual Toys® 100% Satisfaction Guarantee!
865 products
-
Tunnel Plug Clear MediumVendor:Tunnel Plug Clear MediumSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$25.88 - Regular price
-
$40.00 - Sale price
-
$25.88
Quick view
-
Excavate Tunnel Anal Plug BlackVendor:Excavate Tunnel Anal Plug BlackMaster Series
- Regular price
-
$24.88 - Regular price
-
$39.00 - Sale price
-
$24.88
Quick view
-
Playboy Tux Large Metal Anal Plug HematiteVendor:Playboy Tux Large Metal Anal Plug HematiteSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$22.88 - Regular price
-
$36.00 - Sale price
-
$22.88
Quick view
-
Oxballs Glowhole-2 Buttplug With Led Insert Large Clear FrostVendor:Oxballs Glowhole-2 Buttplug With Led Insert Large Clear FrostSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$75.89 - Regular price
-
$113.00 - Sale price
-
$75.89
Quick view
-
Blush Luxe Wearable Vibra Slim Plug Medium - PurpleVendor:Blush Luxe Wearable Vibra Slim Plug Medium - PurpleBlush
- Regular price
-
$17.88 - Regular price
-
$29.00 - Sale price
-
$17.88
Quick view
-
Icicles No 84 With Rechargeable Vibrator & RemoteVendor:Icicles No 84 With Rechargeable Vibrator & RemotePipedream
- Regular price
-
$68.89 - Regular price
-
$103.00 - Sale price
-
$68.89
Quick view
-
Icicles No 26 Glass Butt Plug ClearVendor:Icicles No 26 Glass Butt Plug ClearPipedream
- Regular price
-
$32.88 - Regular price
-
$49.00 - Sale price
-
$32.88
Quick view
-
B-Vibe Snug Plug 2
Quick view
-
B-Vibe Snug Plug 4 Black 9Oz WeightVendor:B-Vibe Snug Plug 4 Black 9Oz WeightB-Vibe
- Regular price
-
$57.89 - Regular price
-
$87.00 - Sale price
-
$57.89
Quick view
-
Strap-On-Me Dildo Plug P&G M Metallic LilacVendor:Strap-On-Me Dildo Plug P&G M Metallic LilacSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$39.88 - Regular price
-
$59.00 - Sale price
-
$39.88
Quick view
-
Xplay Finger Grip Plug #5 L 7 Insertable & 8.5" Circum "Vendor:Xplay Finger Grip Plug #5 L 7 Insertable & 8.5" Circum "Sexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$37.88 - Regular price
-
$57.00 - Sale price
-
$37.88
Quick view
-
Evolved Advanced Vibrating Rechargeable Metal Plug - BlackVendor:Evolved Advanced Vibrating Rechargeable Metal Plug - BlackEvolved
- Regular price
-
$48.89 - Regular price
-
$75.00 - Sale price
-
$48.89
Quick view
-
Evolved Plug & Play Remote Anal Plug - BlackVendor:Evolved Plug & Play Remote Anal Plug - BlackEvolved
- Regular price
-
$68.89 - Regular price
-
$103.00 - Sale price
-
$68.89
Quick view
-
A-Play Thrust Advent Plug W/Remote TealVendor:A-Play Thrust Advent Plug W/Remote TealDoc Johnson
- Regular price
-
$88.89 - Regular price
-
$130.00 - Sale price
-
$88.89
Quick view
-
Pink Elite Collection Supreme Anal Play Kit PinkVendor:Pink Elite Collection Supreme Anal Play Kit PinkSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$31.88 - Regular price
-
$47.00 - Sale price
-
$31.88
Quick view
-
Rosy Gold Nouveau Butt PlugVendor:Rosy Gold Nouveau Butt PlugSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$25.88 - Regular price
-
$40.00 - Sale price
-
$25.88
Quick view
-
Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Large Silver/DiamondVendor:Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Large Silver/DiamondSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$12.88 - Regular price
-
$22.00 - Sale price
-
$12.88
Quick view
-
Shots Ouch! Heart Gem Butt Plug Small Silver/Rubellite PinkVendor:Shots Ouch! Heart Gem Butt Plug Small Silver/Rubellite PinkSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
-
Realrock Crystal Clear 3.5 In. Anal Plug PurpleVendor:Realrock Crystal Clear 3.5 In. Anal Plug PurpleSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$7.88 - Regular price
-
$15.00 - Sale price
-
$7.88
Quick view
-
Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Small Silver/Ruby RedVendor:Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Small Silver/Ruby RedSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
-
Shots Ouch! Heart Gem Butt Plug Medium Silver/Rubellite PinkVendor:Shots Ouch! Heart Gem Butt Plug Medium Silver/Rubellite PinkSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$9.88 - Regular price
-
$19.00 - Sale price
-
$9.88
Quick view
-
Realrock Crystal Clear 3.5 In. Anal Plug BlackVendor:Realrock Crystal Clear 3.5 In. Anal Plug BlackSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$6.88 - Regular price
-
$15.00 - Sale price
-
$6.88
Quick view
-
Realrock Crystal Clear 3.5 In. Anal Plug BlueVendor:Realrock Crystal Clear 3.5 In. Anal Plug BlueSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$6.88 - Regular price
-
$15.00 - Sale price
-
$6.88
Quick view
-
Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Medium Silver/Ruby RedVendor:Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Medium Silver/Ruby RedSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$9.88 - Regular price
-
$19.00 - Sale price
-
$9.88
Quick view
-
Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Small Silver/DiamondVendor:Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Small Silver/DiamondSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$8.88 - Regular price
-
$17.00 - Sale price
-
$8.88
Quick view
-
Shots Ouch! Heart Gem Butt Plug Medium Gunmetal/AmethystVendor:Shots Ouch! Heart Gem Butt Plug Medium Gunmetal/AmethystSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$12.88 - Regular price
-
$22.00 - Sale price
-
$12.88
Quick view
-
Realrock Crystal Clear 4.5 In. Anal Plug PinkVendor:Realrock Crystal Clear 4.5 In. Anal Plug PinkSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$13.88 - Regular price
-
$24.00 - Sale price
-
$13.88
Quick view
-
Realrock Crystal Clear 4.5 In. Anal Plug PurpleVendor:Realrock Crystal Clear 4.5 In. Anal Plug PurpleSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$13.88 - Regular price
-
$24.00 - Sale price
-
$13.88
Quick view
-
Realrock Crystal Clear 4.5 In. Anal Plug BlackVendor:Realrock Crystal Clear 4.5 In. Anal Plug BlackSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$13.88 - Regular price
-
$23.00 - Sale price
-
$13.88
Quick view
-
Shots Ouch! Heart Gem Butt Plug Large Gold/Ruby RedVendor:Shots Ouch! Heart Gem Butt Plug Large Gold/Ruby RedSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$15.88 - Regular price
-
$26.00 - Sale price
-
$15.88
Quick view
-
Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Medium Gunmetal/DiamondVendor:Shots Ouch! Round Gem Butt Plug Medium Gunmetal/DiamondSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$11.88 - Regular price
-
$21.00 - Sale price
-
$11.88
Quick view
-
Jet Annihilator Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugVendor:Jet Annihilator Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugBlush
- Regular price
-
$40.88 - Regular price
-
$60.00 - Sale price
-
$40.88
Quick view
-
Jet Stealth Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugVendor:Jet Stealth Carbon Metallic Black Butt PlugJet Line
- Regular price
-
$14.88 - Regular price
-
$26.00 - Sale price
-
$14.88
Quick view
-
D-Tunnel Plug MediumVendor:D-Tunnel Plug MediumSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$29.88 - Regular price
-
$46.00 - Sale price
-
$29.88
Quick view
-
Nixie Metal Butt Plug Set Pom Pom And Jewel-Inlaid Metallic BlueVendor:Nixie Metal Butt Plug Set Pom Pom And Jewel-Inlaid Metallic BlueSexual Toys®
- Regular price
-
$21.88 - Regular price
-
$34.00 - Sale price
-
$21.88
Quick view
-
Nixie Metal Butt Plug Set Pom Pom And Jewel-Inlaid Metallic PinkVendor:Nixie Metal Butt Plug Set Pom Pom And Jewel-Inlaid Metallic PinkPink
- Regular price
-
$21.88 - Regular price
-
$34.00 - Sale price
-
$21.88
Quick view
-
Vibrating White Fox Tail Slender Anal PlugVendor:Vibrating White Fox Tail Slender Anal PlugTailz
- Regular price
-
$48.89 - Regular price
-
$75.00 - Sale price
-
$48.89
Quick view
-
Frisky Smooth Vibrating Anal PlugVendor:Frisky Smooth Vibrating Anal PlugFrisky
- Regular price
-
$9.88 - Regular price
-
$19.00 - Sale price
-
$9.88
Quick view
-
Frisky Thrill Anal Plug SetVendor:Frisky Thrill Anal Plug SetFrisky
- Regular price
-
$18.88 - Regular price
-
$31.00 - Sale price
-
$18.88
Quick view
-
Gape Glory Clear Hollow Anal Plug LargeVendor:Gape Glory Clear Hollow Anal Plug LargeMaster Series
- Regular price
-
$16.88 - Regular price
-
$28.00 - Sale price
-
$16.88
Quick view
The Butt Plugs Collection features the industry's leading sexual toys and novelty product manufacturers. We appreciate your desire for a large selection and high quality. We ship these in-stock items multiple times per day for lightening fast order processing. Thank you for shopping with us, click the button below to return to the home page.